Whisky review: Morris Whisky’s Signature and Muscat Barrel, and Highwayman Batch SC#01

featured image
On tasting: Morris Signature Single Malt, Muscat Barrels Single Malt and Highwayman Single Malt Batch SC#1

At first glance, this is just a taste of three new whiskies matured in fortified wine casks that have attracted a lot of recent attention and hype. But dig a little deeper, and there are contrasts here which reflect some broader movements in the Australian industry.

I’ve always been curious as to why more Australian wineries, like Morris of Rutherglen, haven’t dabbled in whisky making. Many have the skills, equipment (old stills) and ingredients to create quality spirit, and with ready access to the casks that Aussie whisky makers rely so heavily on, it seems like a no brainer to me.

And while some of Australia’s most significant wine personalities are involved with some of Australia’s biggest whisky brands, Morris’s entry into the market is the first significant leap across by a winemaker. I’d be surprised if it’s the last.

The way Morris have leaned so heavily on international expertise, especially Scottish, is also notable. That tutelage has resulted in a more Scottish-style Australian malt: it’s less oak-forward, more spirit driven, the bottle looks like it’s emerged fresh out of River Spey, and most significantly, it’s affordable, thanks to the scale and success of Casella Family Brands.

Dan Woolley’s first solely Byron-Bay produced malt, on the other hand, is the opposite to the Morris project. Dan spoke to me last year about his desire to keep things small scale, limited and high quality, following the path trodden by Tasmanian distilleries, particularly the likes of Tim Duckett with Heartwood.

The Highwayman whiskies have made good on that promise, and Dan’s hugely rich and cask-forward whiskies have deservedly won him a legion of devoted fans.

Now, I’m not trying to pit these two approaches against each other in some malt whisky grudge match. Personally, I just like to revel in the variety we’re getting to taste and explore these days, and there’s plenty of that on show here.

  • Morris Single Malt Whisky Signature
    The Stats
    • ABV: 40%
    • Price Band: $ $ $ $ $
    • Style: Single malt whisky
    • Production Story: Starts with wash produced at a Casella-owned brewery which is then distilled at the Copper & Grain Distilling Co in a restored 1933 hybrid pot column. The spirit is then matured in a blend of French and American oak ex-wine barrels sourced from wineries in the Barossa and Coonawarra and then finished in a combination of Morris fortified wine barrels.
    • Location: Rutherglen, VIC
    • Score: 86
    Nose
    Salted caramel, treacle and dried raisins. There's a slight nutty funk here as well, possibly spirit sulphur or from the casks. With time, hints of grape must, toasted oak and burnt butter.
    Palate
    Less cask influence than the nose suggests (very refreshing). The fruits from the spirit, mandarin and peaches, are given room to shine, and it picks up mince pie and cloves as it moves along. A few touches of youth, but otherwise, very composed and light to medium-bodied overall.
    Finish
    Not the longest here, but does enough. Doesn't lose too much at 40%.
    Comments
    For the price, this ticks all the boxes. It's very Scottish in its design, but those wine and fortified casks tie it brilliantly to Morris's history and wine practice, and the old still has helped to create something that's just a little bit different. It's not as complex and well-rounded as the Muscat offering, but I actually think this makes for more interesting drinking. One of the best executed first release Australian malts to come out in a while.
  • Morris Single Malt Whisky Muscat Barrel
    The Stats
    • ABV: 46%
    • Price Band: $ $ $ $ $
    • Style: Single malt whisky
    • Production Story: The same distillate and initial maturation as above but this time finished in barrels which were previously used to house Morris Muscat.
    • Location: Rutherglen
    • Score: 88
    Nose
    Similar treacle and funk to the Signature, but the Morris Muscat influence is immediately apparent. Brandy butter, dark chocolate and those musty grape notes again. Citrusy fruits, too - orange oil and lemon pith.
    Palate
    More decadent and rich here. Roasted coffee beans, carob and cinnamon, spice and fruit cake from the muscat. No overt tannin here, though. Luscious and rich but not woody.
    Finish
    More length and carry here with the higher ABV. Dessert territory.
    Comments
    Again, refreshing in its design and structure. The influence of those incredible Muscat casks is on show, but you're not getting splintered in the mouth with timber. There's really no overt woodiness here whatsoever, and it would be interesting to find out if that's due to the treatment of the casks or other decisions made in maturation. Again, an impressive start.
  • Highwayman Single Malt Whisky Batch SC#01
    The Stats
    • ABV: 55%
    • Price Band: $ $ $ $ $
    • Style: Single malt whisky
    • Production Story: The spirit for this batch was mashed, fermented and distilled by Dan Woolley at Lord Byron Distillery. Matured in a 100 litre Spanish oak Pedro Ximenez cask for 2.5 years and bottled in May 2021. 87 bottles made available.
    • Location: Byron Bay, NSW
    • Score: 85
    Nose
    Figs, dates, brown sugar and lots of sherry.... I mean lots of sherry - it's the colour of prune juice this stuff. There's an umami note as it opens up, hickory barbecue sauce, and lots of juicy dark fruits.
    Palate
    Rich and thick with sherry. Molasses, toffee and cinnamon teacake, and a touch of spirit heat. More raisiny and fruity with a drop of water, and the Spanish oak becomes more discernible - black tea and charred wood.
    Finish
    Big sherry sweetness, with flashes of tar and cherry ripe.
    Comments
    Everything’s quality here, and the tannin has been really well managed, despite the overwhelming influence of the cask. For me, the spirit is dominated by that cask, and I was looking forward to getting more of a look at the spirit considering its provenance. But if this style's to your tastes (and I'll admit, it's not really to mine), then you will freaking love this, and I know there's a huge fan base for malts like this in Australia.
Luke McCarthy
Luke McCarthy is the editor and publisher of Oz Whisky Review. An independent writer, author and drinks columnist, Luke's written about whisky and spirits for numerous Australian and international publications and is a judge at the Australian Distilled Spirits Awards. His book, The Australian Spirits Guide, the first to tackle the history and resurgence of the Australian spirits industry, was published in 2016 by Hardie Grant Books.